The games people play.
A quick look at ‘gamification’.
I’ve been meaning to write about gamification for a while now. The following are some thoughts I’ve had for a while, but a couple of weeks ago I visited Bournemouth University for their 3rd annual Promotional Communications Conference, and this gave me the kick up the arse I needed to put pen to paper. [As an aside, this was a great event, with some really interesting research — well done to all involved.] Onwards.
In short, brands are doing gamification wrong.
It’s a term that gets banded around quite a bit, but so we can address it here as a solid practice rather than a fluffy buzz word let’s define it. Gamification, as described by Gabe Zichermann and Christopher Cunningham in Gamification By Design, is the ‘process of game-thinking and game mechanics to engage users and solve problems’.
This all sounds great, but there’s a simple problem. Games are an outlet for play, but more often than not, the process of gamification corrupts play. And when this happens, the benefits intended from the process are diluted, or at worst, lost completely.
Play clearly isn’t a new phenomenon. People have been playing for some time now, and people have been studying play for some time as well. The sociologist Huizinga studied play in the early 20th Century. He described play like this: ‘a free activity… standing outside ordinary life as not serious, but at the same time absorbing the player intensely…’
Part of this conceptualisation of play is the idea of autotelicism. This means that the goal of play — the reason for it — resides purely in the activity itself. The reason people play is intrinsic to the act of playing. Let’s put it this way — when you were a child, did you play games with your friends in order to collect badges and accrue points, or because it was fun? The latter? Thought so.
Get Joe Wood’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
This is where gamification runs into problems. When something is ‘gamified’ the purpose of the gamified thing is usually extrinsic to the game created. As this happens the true value of play is lost, and this renders the process pointless.
Presumably, when a brand gamifies something it does so because it recognises the value of play. Generally speaking, people attach positive associations to the act of play. Theoretically, if a brand can successfully facilitate play those positive associations can be transferred to the brand.
However, more often than not, when a brand does gamification there’s a marketing/business objective lurking at its foundation and this ulterior motive gets in the way. This extrinsic motive will stop truly compelling games being developed. And if a game isn’t truly compelling people won’t want to play.
All this said, I’m not suggesting that gamification is entirely useless and that we should give up on it. I’m just saying that if we’re serious about making it work we need to start with play. Start with an intrinsic goal that people will love. This will lead to games that are good for people and good for brands too.
Here’s a couple of ways I think brands can do good with gamification:
- Start with intrinsic. Create something that people will play. Watch them play and if there’s space for extrinsic value add it later. Look at the Nike Running app — running is the thing at its heart, and truth be told that’s probably adding sufficient value to the brand. But for those who might want it, Nike has added an easy route to the Nike store within it. It’s not in the way, and it’s certainly not crucial to the app, but it’s there if people want it.
- Create space for and foster play throughout your business. This way, people won’t be able to tell the difference. eBay is exemplar here. The whole eBay experience is laced with play (whether this was deliberate or not). For example, competitive games can be found in the auction process at the heart of the business — people often talk of the thrill of beating of others to ‘win’ items. Or, games of chance are represented by the possibility of getting lucky or finding rare items. Playing at role-play is also fostered as eBay users can effortlessly switch between buyer and seller, or frivolously bid on ridiculous items such as yachts or luxury cars that they have no intention of buying… Allowing people space to play has been far from detrimental to eBay’s bottom line.
In short, gamification will work best if it’s based not on badges, or points, or mayorships, but on the very reason games exist — play.







